clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Crew Stadium Moments: Honorable Mentions

Before revealing our No. 1 moment, here are a few that just missed the cut.

New York Red Bulls v Columbus Crew SC - Eastern Conference Finals - Leg 1 Photo by Kirk Irwin/Getty Images

Massive Report is nearly at the end of our countdown of the 15 most memorable moments in Crew Stadium history based on voting from the staff. Join the discussion on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram using the hashtag #MRStadium.


Throughout these last couple of weeks, the Massive Report staff has counted down these Crew Stadium moments. The 14 moments you have seen thus far undoubtedly deserved their spot on the final list with our top moment still set to be announced.

But a number of the Massive Report staff members included moments in their personal top-15 lists that missed the final cut. In fact, up to 30 moments were considered for this countdown and multiple just missed out. Here are five honorable mention moments from our list.

2015 Eastern Conference Final First Leg

The Sunday before Thanksgiving in 2015 turned out to be an exciting night in Columbus Crew history. The first leg of the Eastern Conference Final between the Crew and New York Red Bulls ended in a 2-0 win for the Black & Gold. The moment of this game happened within the first 10 seconds when Justin Meram scored the fastest goal in MLS Cup playoff history. Kei Kamara sealed it late as Columbus was well on its way to its first conference title since 2008.

2015 MLS Cup

If the result was different, the 2015 MLS Cup would have made the list. The 2-1 MLS Cup Final loss to the Portland Timbers was a memorable evening in Crew Stadium for various reasons. The second of three MLS Cup Finals hosted in Columbus featured the hometown team. Unlike the last home game, the Crew conceded after 27 seconds through goalkeeper Steve Clark’s error that allowed Diego Valeri to poke in a goal.

Things went from bad to worse in the seventh minute when Tony Tchani correctly saw the ball go out of bounds but the referee didn’t. This led to a quick Timbers play and ensuing goal by Rodney Wallace. Kamara did score 11 minutes later but the Black & Gold couldn’t find an equalizer. A sad but historic night at Crew Stadium.

Dos a Cero 2005

The United States vs. Mexico game at Crew Stadium in 2005 is the only “Dos a Cero” not included in our countdown. The early September clash was the third match between the two CONCACAF rivals in Columbus and it resulted, once again, in a 2-0 victory for the Americans. Steve Ralston and DeMarcus Beasley scored the goals that clinched a win to send the USA to the 2006 World Cup in Germany.

The final tournament itself was a disappointment with the Americans exiting in the group stage after losses to the Czech Republic and Ghana. But the Americans did tied the eventual winners Italy 1-1.

The Crew vs. Atlanta United Flood Game

Late March in 2019 was a night that can be described in one word: soaking. The Crew hosted the defending MLS Cup champions, Atlanta United, at MAPFRE Stadium in a torrential downpour for nearly the entire game. It was raining sideways with force and it didn’t cease at all. Pedro Santos and Gyasi Zardes scored the two goals in the victory against Atlanta and as soon as the final whistle blew, every person on that pitch rushed indoors.

2015 Eastern Conference Semifinal Second Leg

The Columbus match against the Montreal Impact in early November is another 2015 playoff battle at Crew Stadium that just missed the cut. After losing in Montreal 2-1, the Crew needed a strong home performance to advance to the Eastern Conference Final.

Kamara scored in the fourth minute but the Impact equalized in the 40th. Ethan Finlay then struck the second for Columbus to take the match to extra time. The Crew won the game in the 111th minute when Kamara scored his second to send the Black & Gold to the Eastern Conference Final.

Other Nominated Moments

2020 Eastern Conference Final: Artur goal wins Crew third East title

2018 SheBelieves Cup: the United States beats Germany 1-0

2000 MLS All-Star Game: a 13-goal thriller in Crew Stadium’s first All-State Game

Hell is Real (2019): A Pedro Santos rocket earns a point in first MLS match against FC Cincinnati

USA vs. Mexico (2016): The first and only loss to Mexico in Columbus

2002 World Cup watch parties

Dominic Oduro pizza celebration: Oduro ate pizza after scoring a goal


Read Massive Report’s Crew Stadium Moments that did make the list

No. 2: Dos a Cero 2001

No. 3: The first game at Crew Stadium

No. 4: 2008 Eastern Conference Final

No. 5: Dos a Cero 2013

No. 6: Dos A Cero 2009

No. 7: 2017 Halloween playoff win over NYCFC

No. 8: 2003 Women’s World Cup

No. 9: The Legends Game

No. 10: Landon Donovan, Earthquakes win first MLS Cup

No. 11: The 2002 U.S. Open Cup championship

No. 12: Wil Trapp’s miracle game winner

No. 13: The scoreboard fire

No. 14: 2005 MLS All-Star Game

No. 15: The first game after Kirk Urso’s passing